Sunday, May 5, 2024

28.04.24: greatness and immortality

Since I was talking about “greatness” in the previous post, I wanted to share a small part of my own research on Pliny because I think it shows part of the Roman “value system”.

Written around 106-107 AD Epistula 6.16 is Pliny’s response to the request made by the Roman politician and historian Publius Cornelius Tacitus to furnish him with the details of Pliny the Elder’s death - he died during the eruption of Vesuvius in AD79 - in order for this to be included in the former’s historical chronicles. The Historiae of Tacitus were published c.110-111 but the surviving work only reaches AD70. Therefore, if Tacitus did ultimately refer to the death of Pliny the Elder in the chronicles, there is no confirmation of that although, given that Pliny the Elder was an eminent scholar, author, commander and prominent figure in Rome, being a personal friend of the Emperor Vespasian, there is equally no reason to assume that Tacitus would have omitted him. Nevertheless, what transpires in the opening remarks of 6.16 is Pliny’s determination to ensure that it is included.

In responding to Tacitus’ request, Pliny the Younger joins the march of an historico-literary tradition that precedes him by centuries and has continued ever since: the criteria for the task that Pliny is now willing, indeed demanding to fulfil were already set in stone by the funerary epitaph of Scipio Barbatus, consul in 298BC.

Those three criteria are not only set in stone, but set precisely in the middle of the stone and all on the same line [image #1].

FORTIS (strong; brave) │SAPIENS (wise) │VIRTVS (virtue)

The other interesting aspect of this tomb inscription is a language structure known as the “rule of three”, a technique still used in our advertising i.e. three pieces of memorable information, a technique used by Cicero and, indeed, by our politicians today. That rule of three continues on the next line that states Scipio’s positions of authority:

CONSOL │ CENSOR │ AEDILIS

Cornelius Lucius Scipio Barbatus, Gnaeo patre prognatus, fortis vir sapiensque, cuius forma virtuti parissima fuit, ConsulCensorAedilis, qui fuit apud vos; Taurasiam Cisaunam, Samnio cepit, subigit omnem Lucaniam, obsidesque abducit.

Cornelius Lucius Scipio Barbatus, sprung from Gnaeus his father, a man strong and wise, whose appearance was most in keeping with his virtue, who was consulcensor, and aedile among you – He captured Taurasia Cisauna in Samnium – he subdued all of Lucania and led off hostages.

In the ancient world being remembered mattered: Ramesses II ordered his cartouches to be so deeply carved in the columns at Karnak that they could never be erased, and the inscriptions known as res gestae Divini Augusti gave a first-person account of the life achievements of the Emperor.

But the desire for eternal memory was not the exclusive domain of pharaos, emperors and consuls: the tombstones of far less illustrious Romans frequently give considerably more information than the name, date of birth and date of death, historians gaining insights into, for example, the deceased’s manner of death, occupation, accomplishments and personal characteristics. Indeed, even the hypostyle chamber of the 6th century cistern of Philoxenos at Constantinople (Istanbul) bears the masons’ marks on the columns, as deeply carved as the cartouches of Ramesses and similarly withstanding the test of time and water erosion.

Immortality, of course, was not only achieved in stone but most often in the chronicles of the most notable Roman authors, chronicles that would be read by the most notable Roman citizens. The poet Horace believes that he does not require the testimony of others, but that his own works will speak on his behalf:

exegi monumentum aere perennius

regalique situ pyramidum altius,

quod non imber edax, non Aquilo inpotens

possit diruere…

[Odes III: XXX, ll1-4, published 23BC]

I have built a monument more lasting than bronze,

higher than the Pyramids’ regal structures,

that no consuming rain, nor wild north wind

can destroy…

And, what’s interesting, of course, is that, over 2000 years later, we still remember them.

Nike might be proud of its memorable rule of three advertising slogan: Just Do It, but the Romans were doing just that long before Nike ever did. I wonder if Nike will last 2000 years.






No comments: